Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
veryunlucky

Which is worse? Oral Hsv1 or Oral Hsv2?

15 posts in this topic

Does anyone know which is worse to have? Oral 1 or oral 2? And why? Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The main difference between hsv1 and hsv2 is their site of preference. HSV1 prefers oral and HSV2 prefers genital. While you can get either one in either site if you get HSV1 genital it typically is not as bad as HSV2 genital. The same goes for HSV2 oral it typically isn't as bad as HSV1 oral.

But everyone is different. Some people don't suffer at all with genital HSV2 and some people do suffer with HSV1 genital. It really has to do with a person's immune system. If they do not have a good immune system they may tend to suffer with either 1 or 2.

Come to the Chat Room, there you will meet many nice fellow Herpsters who can offer you their support.

Good luck!

JB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another point in this discussion is the likelihood of passing HSV along to someone else.

Most folks who have a type of HSV that is "out of place" from the site of preference have fewer outbreaks. So that would apply to Genital HSV1 and Oral HSV2.

Not only do they they have fewer outbreaks, they also have less frequent asymptomatic viral shedding.

So when the virus type is "out of place," it is less likely to be spread to another person.

Oral HSV2 is considered the least likely of the 4 possible combinations to reoccur, and the least likely to shed, so theoretically it is also the least likely to spread.

:wavey:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your replies I really appreciate it! Can Hsv 1 be predominately inside your mouth rather than outside your lips? My symptoms are inside my mouth and on the sides of my cheeks like patches of small white blisters. They also occur on the roof of my mouth and on my gums. I am so worried it is 2 due to the stigma attached.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for your replies I really appreciate it! Can Hsv 1 be predominately inside your mouth rather than outside your lips? My symptoms are inside my mouth and on the sides of my cheeks like patches of small white blisters. They also occur on the roof of my mouth and on my gums. I am so worried it is 2 due to the stigma attached.

The stigma is attached to the location, not the strain. The stigma is all about it being associated with having sex, which goes to our pseudo-Victorian morality.

It's really silly, because we all (for the most part) want to have sex. But then we disparage other folks when they do. Ridiculous. :(

HSV1 and HSV2 are almost identical, even when looking at the DNA under a microscope. The sores do not look any different, even if they were outside your mouth.

Even if you do have Oral HSV2, nobody can look at you and say, "Oh, you have HSV2, not HSV1!" So if all you have is OHSV, you will likely skip out on the attached stigma, for the most part.

It is all a manufactured, false stigma anyway. It did not exist until a few decades ago, even though herpes has been known for over 4000 years. The stigma arose right around the same time acyclovir was invented. What a funny "coincidence!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for your replies I really appreciate it! Can Hsv 1 be predominately inside your mouth rather than outside your lips? My symptoms are inside my mouth and on the sides of my cheeks like patches of small white blisters. They also occur on the roof of my mouth and on my gums. I am so worried it is 2 due to the stigma attached.

Hi there, I've been diagnosed with Oral HSV2, and mine is exclusively inside my mouth. My initial outbreak presented as a very sore, infected throat (which doctors initially thought was strep, but did a culture and found out was HSV2), along with bumps in the back of my mouth and on the side of my tongue. I also had a fever, fatigue, swollen lymph nodes. I've never had a cold sore outside my mouth at all. I've read that HSV1 is more likely to present as cold sores while HSV2 is more likely to be inside the mouth when acquired orally, but I don't know if this always holds true.

I'm encouraged to read people saying that Oral HSV2 is the least likely to recur, shed, and spread, but after being diagnosed less than 2 months ago, I'm already having another mild outbreak on the side of my tongue. So I'm not sure if I'll be one of the lucky ones whose HSV doesn't recur. I guess I just have to wait and see what kind of pattern develops over the coming months.

As for the original question, I don't think you can really say either type is "worse," other than the fact that Oral HSV2 is more rare and makes me personally feel like a bit of a freak for having it, since everyone thinks HSV2 is "genital". And on the practical side, it means it's a lot harder to find accurate information about this particular form of HSV because of it being a rare combination. But I'm trying to just take it day by day and not worry too much about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To the person of the first question:

HSV2 is worse orally!!!, but then again, hsv2 orally;you dont really get ob's because its not in its comfortable state to get ob's. You get less ob's but then again everyone is different. HSV1 is most common for coldsores above the waistline. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the fact that people think that herpes 1 and 2 have a place of preference i don't think that is true i have hsv oral 2 i have 3 or more ob a month if you have oral sex with someone that has genital type 2 you will have oral type 2 the virus don't care where it is it don't say opps wrong place can't go there.i also have type one on my butt cheeks it don't mind being there just my thoughts

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

clarke53,

Hi, were u diagnosed (orally) thru a swab test? What are your oral symptoms? How long have you had oral type2? Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes oral swab had it for 4 years now i get a shallow ulser on the lower inside of lip and i get obs on the inside of my cheeks i use h-balm for them and it works great but not so good on hsv type 2 on my butt cheeks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh and for me hsv 1 is worse even though i get 3 or more obs a month with the oral i can control them with h-balm as soon as one comes on i put a dab on and there gone in a day or two.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi....im New to this site and to herpes. So my question, what is the difference between hsv 1 gential to hsv 2 genital and hsv 1 oral to hsv 2 oral ? I have hsv 2 oral and everyone says that is very rare !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi....im New to this site and to herpes. So my question, what is the difference between hsv 1 gential to hsv 2 genital and hsv 1 oral to hsv 2 oral ? I have hsv 2 oral and everyone says that is very rare !

There isn't a really easy answer to your question, Matmaria. The thing is, each person has a different experience with HSV from every other person, no matter where they have it or what type. Many folks who have HSV are not even aware they do, because they have such mild symptoms (or none at all). But others have a very tough time with symptoms, at least at first.

This article might help a bit, though:

"Good" Virus/"Bad" Virus -- the Truth About HSV-I and HSV-II

:wavey:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Latest Buzz

    • VVK
      Is there a reason that you're still staying with him? Also how do you know it's HSV-1? Were you diagnosed through swab/blood test? And how were you tested when you got your HSV negative status prior to all of this? One of my ex-gf's used to get BV - I found a way to fix that by making sure that we were both showered/bathed prior to to having sex and her afterwards. However, if it's the semen that's causing your issues then just don't let him ejaculate inside of you. He should at least be sensitive enough to understand that BV is no fun and if he's the problem, he needs to deal with it.  
    • Free73
      They cannot take a swab unless a sore is present. Sarah, please go and take an IGG blood test if you want further confirmation
    • Lisajd
      He may have hsv1 oral or genital so thats how you received it
    • Lisajd
      In order to move forward you need to manage symptoms.  Are you on anti virals.  This anger eycay contribute to your symptoms.  Stress is not good for herpes.  Did you get tested for hsv as its not standard in your initial test.  What exactly do you have and what does he have.  You say your negative for 1 and but he has herpes.  Need to clarify.  
    • Lisajd
      Look you have hsv1 which provides some immunity. He had sex with prostitutes who you dont even know have hsv2 plus he used a condom.  I think you either go get tested or accept you are unlikely to have hsv2. No one here can diagnose you.
    • VVK
      Out of all the possible outcomes, this one is as good as it gets for being HSV positive. If you're not sticking around here, I hope you will provide us with an update a few months down the road to tell us how you're doing.
    • Sarahbby28
      So they can't swab without sore ? Yeh he said he doesn't but he never has been tested his been to about 10-15 prositutes I dunno if that puts him at higher risk was with Condom
    • cantdoit
      Absolutely they can.  To see if they can pick up virus. It's needs to be a PCR swab. 
    • muse93
      He didn't have a cold sore, and I've never seen him with one. We just had vaginal intercourse when this happened to me. We have had oral sex before, but I never had a reaction like after sex. We also have a long distance relationship so we have sex every 3-6 months.  My OB/GYN swabbed my vagina when I went in for the bacteria infection. 
    • Lisajd
      They would do a blood test if its likely to be 3 months from infection.  Have you asked the ex if he has hsv2
  • Featured