Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
glassofwine

Anyone been wrongfully diagnosed with genital herpes, when it was shingles?

9 posts in this topic

Hi,

I went in to see the doctor because I had genital, butt and thigh pain. She could not see any sores, and I have yet to see any myself. I got the IgM test done, and it came back positive and the IgG was negative. I know it's not very accurate, so I feel I have to wait 2 more months to confirm this.

But I know that the test can pick up on other herpes infections like chickenpox, and shingles. Has anyone here had that happen? I know shingles can manifest the same symptoms as genital herpes, so I'm thinking there is a chance I may have that. I think I definitely have something because the Valtrex has helped with the pain...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chicken pox or shingles will not show up as hsv1 or hsv2. And I have met a LOT of people on this site who were POSITIVE they had herpes and later found out they did not. There are many things that can cause similar symptoms. Just wait a couple of months and test again.

Good luck!

JB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IgM isn't reliable as it does pick up chicken pox, Epstein Barr, etc.... Your igG negative is a good sign, but how long has it been since you think you were exposed?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been about 6 weeks, which means i still have to wait 6 more weeks to retest. It's really killing me! At this point i'm pretty sure I have something herpes related, whether its genital herpes or shingles. The reason is that I've been taking Valtrex and that has reduced my pain. I went off of it for a day, when the 10 day treatment was over, and the pain returned....so I'm pretty sure I have herpes of some kind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The danger of thinking that way is two-fold... if you don't have it you've overlooking something that may need attention by assuming it's something else, and at 12 weeks when you are still possibly negative, you won't believe it... Believe me, I've been there, at 6 months I have all negatives and am still not 100% convinced. I was convinced for a bit, but then the pain returned, starting a whole new wave of paranoia...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you recently have sex with someone who you suspect may have herpes?

I would find it highly strange that it was 'shingles' if you recently had sex....

but in any event...it may help to get tested again just to be sure. :)

Best of luck to you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bob- aren't you the one that has already tested negative in many tests, and are already at the 6 month mark!? if so, stop freakin out and be happy! at least u never tested positive for the IgM!

Kitty123- I recently had sex with someone whose sexual history i do not know. i suspect he's pretty promiscuous but that doesn't mean he had herpes...so i guess i just have to wait it out. i just have pain that wont go away :/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, I wish I could... Basically what I was saying was that the experts say IgM tests are unreliable, do a search of medhelp and you'll see Dr. HHH's posts on it. So you're IgM test doesn't mean a whole lot, which is good.

Where I'm stuck is symptoms that line up, no alternate diagnosis, and the time that has evolved, with one recurrence (no visual symptoms the second time). You always see that 3-4 months is conclusive (3 for HerpeSelect, 4 for other IgG). What you don't pay attention to is the little caveat that says, "Without the presence of worrisome symptoms, 3-4 months is conclusive."

So where does that leave us? In this no man limbo land. I had worrisome symptoms, initial red bumps with an icy hot feeling and crazy raw sensitive skin. The partner that I was with said another partner had red bumps after being with her and thought she had repeat outbreaks in the past, but at first she said she was never truly diagnosed visually or serologically, then she said it was cultured but had no idea of the type. Red bumps could be a lot of things, even just irritation, but another partner got irritation starting at 10 days out as well? That would be one crazy coincidence.

Since this last episode last week I've felt more normal than I ever. No more rawness down there, no more stinging, the redness has even dissipated. It's been six months of not being right and all of sudden it's just gone? The recurrence has me more freaked out than ever, yet the symptoms have gone away? My rationale is that if it was all in my head the symptoms would be worse than ever, which they aren't.

I never took antivirals, which should make antibodies appear sooner and hopefully higher. I've seen way too many posts where people had swab positives, yet blood is negative at a much later date. It doesn't make me 100% confident in an "elevated" negative after worrisome symptoms, I wish it could.

I don't want to be one of the cases that proves anyone wrong...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't want to sound like a hypochondriac, it's easy to type in "blood negative swab positive" to a search engine and see a fair amount of people who were swabbed positive and haven't been positive on IgG after years. I kick myself for not going in with the physical symptoms... How can you ever be comfortable when seeing actual cases?

I tried to email HerpeSelect to ask about index values, they just referred me to their website and said to talk to my doctor. I'm sure part of it is CYA, but here's some interesting info on their site.

How long after infection will HerpeSelect detect IgG antibodies?

HerpeSelect can detect HSV IgG antibodies as quickly as 3 weeks after the onset of a patient's symptoms4. It is important to note that each individual may seroconvert at different rate leading to earlier or delayed detection. Some patients do not seroconvert for 6 months or longer.

What confirmatory testing is necessary for HerpeSelect type specific assays?

As with other serological tests, false results may occur. Repeat testing or testing with a different device may be indicated in some circumstances, for example, patients with a low likelihood of HSV infection. All results must be correlated with clinical history, epidemiological data, and other data available to the attending physician in evaluating the patient.

Hearing even experts say 3-4 months is conclusive, even with worrisome symptoms, doesn't jive with the other things you read, but then again I'm no expert.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Latest Buzz

    • Mode
      We tried having sex few weeks ago after 5 months of abstinence but that sex was quick because we were afraid that I might have an outbreak again.. though, I have not gotten anything from that week-ago sex.
    • Lisajd
      I cant answer that.  Some people get an outbreak caused by friction from sex you can only try and see how you go
    • Mode
      So even if we have sex again, i won't get any outbreak? 
    • Lisajd
      There is still no evidence to suggest that a diet high in lysine and low in arginine suppressors outbreak but if it does work for you then it's good to do that however it really is trial and error
    • Lisajd
      A herpes outbreak can be caused by a number of things and in the main it is because of your immune system but the friction from sex can cause an outbreak but any further outbreaks after your first will never be as bad as the first.  You really don't need to abstain from sex if you both have herpes.  It won't cause an outbreak. 
    • Mode
      We have been together for 7 months now. The herpes outbreak I had in February lasted for a week. We are planning to have sex again after 5 months of abstinence. Do you think herpes outbreak will come back? 
    • Tippyty
      That was along time ago. If u are not having one now u should be fine. And u both have herpes. How often u get a outbreak just depends. Everyone is different. I'm glad u stayed together. How long have u to dated and how long have u had it.
    • @lw@ys
      They just haven't removed that link that is all.
    • Mode
      I got genital herpes outbreak last february and it healed in March. I actually got it from my recent boyfriend. We are still together and think of having sex again, is my herpes going to reoccur?
    • Amex
      Thanks for the advice, I surely will go to doctor, bit I'm pretty sure  that this one is cold stores because they also start to appear around my mouth too, i've got now in 2 different zones of the left face and in my left eyebrow also, I'will wait like 2 ore 3 days if this think will get away himself if not I'm obligated to do a visit a doctor.
  • Featured