Jump to content
World's Largest Herpes Support Group
friendlyboy

My small informal trial re Zn(O2COOH3)2

Recommended Posts

friendlyboy

Background:

I've been infected since Feb 2017, symptomatic since May 2017, on suppressive treatment ever since, suffering from extremely frequent symptoms (OBs), as frequent as daily or bi-daily even with suppressive treatment.

Symptoms are the usual pimple-like or folliculitis-like lesions on both inner thighs and occasionally other places from buttocks to knees, which under suppressive treatment usually don't fully develop into blistering lesions.

I've been using Zinc Acetate in several ways ever since first symptoms appeared, inconsistently, firstly as an oral supplement which didn't seem to have any effect, later as a topical application which I wasn't convinced it was of much use though it seemed somewhat beneficial.

As my current stash of Zn(O2COOH3)2 solution was getting close to depletion, I was pondering whether it was worth the effort of preparing more and keep using it.

Since earlier this year I had an unusual 2 month symptom free period, and I think I was consistently topically applying zinc acetate, I decided to run a controlled, as much as I could, experiment to see whether it had any measurable effect or not, actually expecting it not to have any effect.

The trial:

Open-label, no placebo control, crossover trial of topical application of 3% zinc acetate solution on the inner thigh of one leg for one month and no treatment of the other leg under suppressive treatment 250 mg valacyclovir each 8 h, lasting 2 months. Expected result is no difference between treated and untreated.

The experiment would have been better controlled with blinding and a placebo, but zinc acetate solution has a distinct smell so it is not possible to hide which bottle has the solution unless you use another similar smelly acetate salt (such as sodium acetate), which I didn't have available and didn't want to bother looking for it just for this test. I also would have needed a friend to help me prepare the bottles so I wouldn't know which one is which.

Treatment protocol: apply with the hand 2-3 drops of solution on the skin in the area usually affected by lesions rubbing until almost dry, once daily before going to bed or just after showering.

Observed results: around 9-12 lesions were observed daily on the untreated leg after 5-7 days of stopping treatment on that leg, no lesions were observed in the treated area on the opposite leg for the entire month, 1-2 lesions appeared on the treated leg outside the treated area, lesions took around 7 days to disappear after starting treatment on the untreated leg. The same pattern repeated after switching legs.

Observed side effects: very slight erithema after application lasting less than an hour. Slight itching shortly after application on active lesions, lasting around an hour.

Conclusion: treatment seems to have an influence on preventing the appearance of lesions in this particular case. This influence may be marginal and not strong enough to make a difference in other cases.

Possible mechanisms I hypothesize for this effect are:

- Zn2+ ions crossing the skin improve immune response, perhaps by providing micro-nutrients in-place for immune cell replication.

- Zinc acetate draws immune cells closer to the epidermis somehow, perhaps by being slightly irritant, therefore improving immune response on skin viral infection.

- Rubbing the skin increases blood flow through the dermis, allowing more immune cells to reach the skin resulting on increased infiltration upon detection of viral infection.

Edited by friendlyboy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quest

Zinc lactate is supposed to be most effective on HSV 2  92%?  Has to be ordered from a chemical company.

Zinc gluconate works best for hsv1.

DontJuan had a thread on this. I think it was a zinc sulfate thread. It was really interesting to me and I do use it off and on. I was going to order the zinc lactate which is harder to mix in water, but I'm not sure I really need it anymore with my protocol.

Thanks for the information!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Phoenixx

I remember you were very critical about topical treatments. I like the scientific approach.

Do you think that treatment is also ok on penis mucosa or too harsh? Where did you get the zinc acetate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
friendlyboy
8 hours ago, Phoenixx said:

I remember you were very critical about topical treatments. I like the scientific approach.

Do you think that treatment is also ok on penis mucosa or too harsh? Where did you get the zinc acetate?

 I got the zinc acetate from an pharmacy in my town, they can't sell reagents but I know the pharmacist. I cost me about 10 € a 50 gr bottle, enough for a decade at the current rate of consumtion. Otherwise it is quite easy to get, you can buy it from a laboratory or even in ebay.

I apply the treatment on my glans about 2-3 times a week, I've never had any problem or adverse effect so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
VladimirM
On 9/17/2018 at 8:39 PM, friendlyboy said:

Background:

I've been infected since Feb 2017, symptomatic since May 2017, on suppressive treatment ever since, suffering from extremely frequent symptoms (OBs), as frequent as daily or bi-daily even with suppressive treatment.

Symptoms are the usual pimple-like or folliculitis-like lesions on both inner thighs and occasionally other places from buttocks to knees, which under suppressive treatment usually don't fully develop into blistering lesions.

I've been using Zinc Acetate in several ways ever since first symptoms appeared, inconsistently, firstly as an oral supplement which didn't seem to have any effect, later as a topical application which I wasn't convinced it was of much use though it seemed somewhat beneficial.

As my current stash of Zn(O2COOH3)2 solution was getting close to depletion, I was pondering whether it was worth the effort of preparing more and keep using it.

Since earlier this year I had an unusual 2 month symptom free period, and I think I was consistently topically applying zinc acetate, I decided to run a controlled, as much as I could, experiment to see whether it had any measurable effect or not, actually expecting it not to have any effect.

The trial:

Open-label, no placebo control, crossover trial of topical application of 3% zinc acetate solution on the inner thigh of one leg for one month and no treatment of the other leg under suppressive treatment 250 mg valacyclovir each 8 h, lasting 2 months. Expected result is no difference between treated and untreated.

The experiment would have been better controlled with blinding and a placebo, but zinc acetate solution has a distinct smell so it is not possible to hide which bottle has the solution unless you use another similar smelly acetate salt (such as sodium acetate), which I didn't have available and didn't want to bother looking for it just for this test. I also would have needed a friend to help me prepare the bottles so I wouldn't know which one is which.

Treatment protocol: apply with the hand 2-3 drops of solution on the skin in the area usually affected by lesions rubbing until almost dry, once daily before going to bed or just after showering.

Observed results: around 9-12 lesions were observed daily on the untreated leg after 5-7 days of stopping treatment on that leg, no lesions were observed in the treated area on the opposite leg for the entire month, 1-2 lesions appeared on the treated leg outside the treated area, lesions took around 7 days to disappear after starting treatment on the untreated leg. The same pattern repeated after switching legs.

Observed side effects: very slight erithema after application lasting less than an hour. Slight itching shortly after application on active lesions, lasting around an hour.

Conclusion: treatment seems to have an influence on preventing the appearance of lesions in this particular case. This influence may be marginal and not strong enough to make a difference in other cases.

Possible mechanisms I hypothesize for this effect are:

- Zn2+ ions crossing the skin improve immune response, perhaps by providing micro-nutrients in-place for immune cell replication.

- Zinc acetate draws immune cells closer to the epidermis somehow, perhaps by being slightly irritant, therefore improving immune response on skin viral infection.

- Rubbing the skin increases blood flow through the dermis, allowing more immune cells to reach the skin resulting on increased infiltration upon detection of viral infection.

I want to recommend you SADBE 1%. He.. it....helped me a lot. Just put it on your body a few times a day. You will see the results and feel it after the first day. 

I bouth it here.  

https://www.enbipharma.com/sadbe-forte

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ill47

I've seen a bunch of positive studies in the effects of zinc on herpes, but I don't see any products that have resulted from this. Any reasons why? Why aren't more people talking about this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guardianforyou

Are u able to apply it directly on the glans and under the foreskin? Even without lesions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
friendlyboy
18 hours ago, Guardianforyou said:

Are u able to apply it directly on the glans and under the foreskin? Even without lesions?

Yes, that is how I use it, particularly without lesions.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Phoenixx
On 9/20/2018 at 8:18 PM, friendlyboy said:

 I got the zinc acetate from an pharmacy in my town, they can't sell reagents but I know the pharmacist. I cost me about 10 € a 50 gr bottle, enough for a decade at the current rate of consumtion. Otherwise it is quite easy to get, you can buy it from a laboratory or even in ebay.

I apply the treatment on my glans about 2-3 times a week, I've never had any problem or adverse effect so far.

Did you manage to keep your penis skin lesion free until today with that treatment?

I suppose you never stopped the valacyclovir.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Advertisement

Try a Lysine supplement for cold sores

  • The Hive is Thriving!

    • Total Topics
      68,848
    • Total Posts
      460,466
  • Posts

    • emz
      Is someone able to kindly explain to me what synergy products actually do without opinions or disagreements on its effectiveness? For example what ingredients are involved and how does it aim to target the virus. Can't find any info online. Hope someone can help. Many thanks 
    • Roja
      Why is it your worst fear to have GHSV-1? 
    • Miss Horne
      Not sure if this has already been mentioned before, could we donate to his lab? Hsv specifically? 
    • Gems
      It can be very difficult to diagnose I do not know the lab discussed here but I have read about sexual health clinics that no longer use the blood tests for this reason of false negatives. Even swabs can be hard they were in my case.  I know I have it and never resorted to the biopsy.

      Do your own research and consult with GP's. I would assume you have this until its totally ruled out.  

      I read about a person on this site who tested neg on the IgG and pos on the weston blot.

      Please do your own research. 
    • Gems
      If it is an issue why not speak to admin about creating two separate threads...one for those looking at natural management and "supposed" natural cures and one looking at medical breakthroughs. That way both interests are served, no one is offended and people who wish to look at both can. No one is excluded and everyone included. Those who want to stay with the medical threads can. Maybe there will be less issues that way. 

      Personally I would prefer not to engage with those who are seeking vaccines and gene tech ect esp if they are nasty or condescending and prefer to support and encourage like minded without the excessive debates in a supported enviro.

      Just putting it out there.

      @Heatbroken Sydney

       
×

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.